Why Is Not Trying a Survival Response, Not a Weakness? With Josh Trent (Part 2)

There is something you know would help. You have known for a while. You still have not done it.

Most people read that as a motivation problem. It is closer to a protection problem. When effort has felt pointless for long enough, the body stops spending energy on it, even after the situation changes.

I know this one from the inside. I recognized myself in the research on learned helplessness, and it stopped me cold.

The original experiments were run on dogs. The ones who could not escape a shock stopped trying. Later, when escape was easy, they stayed down and took it. Their bodies had learned that nothing they did mattered.

I had lived the human version of that. For a long stretch of my life I expected everything to be hard. I expected to fail. So there were things I simply stopped trying, without ever deciding to.

That is where this conversation with Josh Trent picks up. We recorded it in his studio in Austin, and it is the second half of a longer talk about resting, escaping, and what the body does when it has carried too much for too long.

WHY DID I STOP TRYING WHEN NOTHING WAS STOPPING ME?

Because your nervous system learned that effort did not change anything, and it powered the effort down to protect you.

The updated science is worth knowing. Passivity is not a lesson the body decides to learn. It is the body's default response to prolonged, uncontrollable stress.

What reverses it is a felt sense of control returning, in small amounts. Not a lecture about trying harder.

So if part of you has gone quiet and still, that is not a flaw in your character. It is a body that stopped spending energy on a fight it believed it could not win.

IS NOT TRYING LAZINESS, OR SOMETHING ELSE?

It is a survival response, and it is the opposite of not caring.

Laziness is a choice made by someone who could act and would rather not. This is different.

This is a body that has taken the option to act offline.

I tell the story of Seabiscuit in the final chapter of my book. A horse raced to lose on purpose, until losing was the only thing he knew.

The turn came when he ran for the love of running. The weight of the old programming was no longer holding him back.

WHY DO I HAVE TO GENERATE ENERGY JUST TO SHOW UP?

Because when the body sits in freeze, showing up takes borrowed energy, and you have learned to manufacture it.

For most of my career I generated that energy without knowing it. Exercise, novelty, urgency, a bit of drama. Anything that moved adrenaline through me.

I did it to serve other people. I never once saw it as a survival strategy. It felt like the price of showing up.

Josh calls it a trap, and he thinks most of us have to move through it before we can see it. The fuel works, right up until it does not.

WHY DOESN'T THE DRIVE THAT GOT ME HERE WORK ANYMORE?

Because the fuel was your own wound, and a body cannot run a new life on the pain that started the old one.

Josh names something I see in almost every practitioner. Most of us came into this work because of something we were carrying. The anger, the grief, the frustration became the engine.

That engine takes you far. Then one day the body says it is done, and the old fuel stops igniting.

What comes next is the part people skip. Grieving the old identity fully, so the next one has room to hold.

WHY AM I ONLY HAPPY WHEN THE CONDITIONS ARE RIGHT?

Because you learned a version of happiness that waits on the conditions being met, the money, the body, the picture being complete.

Josh has a name for it. Conditioned happiness. Joy that is allowed only once the gaps are filled.

He watched people brace and posture to look like they have it all together. That bracing cuts a person off from their own body, and others can feel it.

The other kind does not depend on the conditions. It is what is left when you stop performing and come home to who you are.

WHY CAN PEOPLE TELL WHEN SOMETHING IS OFF IN ME?

Because what is felt and not said is still felt, and the body of the person across from you reads it directly.

Josh describes the enteric nervous system, the gut sense, the small muscles of the face that decide in a moment whether we are safe with each other.

A client feels your bracing before they process a word you say. The nervous system is having its own conversation underneath the spoken one.

This is why the inner work is the work. What you have not made peace with in yourself, the people you serve can feel.

HOW MUCH SAFETY DO I NEED BEFORE I CAN CHANGE?

Not as much as you think. You need enough safety for the next step, not for the whole path.

This is the piece I most want you to hold. People wait until they feel safe about everything before they move. That day does not come.

A little safety is enough to get curious. Curious about whether the old story is even true anymore.

You do not need to see the whole way. You need enough ground for the next step, and the step after that reveals itself from there.

HOW DOES CURIOSITY TURN INTO COURAGE?

Curiosity is what dissolves a false choice, and courage is moving with it while the fear is still there.

Josh and I landed here together. Curiosity cannot show up in a body that does not feel safe. Safety has to come first, even a little.

From that little bit of safety, you can ask a question you could not ask before. Does this really have to be one thing or the other.

Courage is not the absence of fear. It is that curiosity, carried into the next step, fear and all.

IN THIS EPISODE

• 02:04 How to tell resting from escaping

• 04:25 The three questions behind your purpose

• 06:48 Why the fuel of your own wound stops working

• 07:58 Grieving the old identity

• 10:05 Why showing up takes borrowed energy

• 13:24 Conditioned happiness and the opposite he found

• 17:18 The Seabiscuit story and learned helplessness

• 21:45 Recognizing the pattern in someone else

• 26:49 What most people misunderstand about a leader

• 30:20 Freedom fuels flow, fear fuels force

• 31:27 Why curiosity needs safety first

Resources/Guides:

• Take the free 2-Minute Assessment for Stored Trauma. Discover your primary pattern of responding when life becomes too much, then see how the other four show up.

• Get The Biology of Trauma book. Read Chapter 13, on why the body will not rest until it feels safe, and how to start building that safety.

Related Podcast Episodes:

• EP 85: Stress & Freeze Response: How to Achieve & Sustain High Performance with Olympian Louise Tjernqvist

• EP 185: Josh Trent on Why We Escape Instead of Rest (Part 1)

• Medical Doctor Reveals: The Science of Healing Trauma From the Inside Out

ABOUT THE GUEST

Josh Trent hosts the Wellness + Wisdom Podcast. He has spent more than twenty years as a trainer and facilitator of body-based work, and teaches a framework he calls Emotional Epigenetics.

RESEARCH

• Maier SF, Seligman MEP. Learned helplessness at fifty: Insights from neuroscience. Psychological Review. 2016;123(4):349-367. On how passivity is the body's default response to prolonged uncontrollable stress, and how regaining a sense of control reverses it.

• Kozlowska K, Walker P, McLean L, Carrive P. Fear and the Defense Cascade: Clinical Implications and Management. Harvard Review of Psychiatry. 2015;23(4):263-287. In the freeze and shutdown states the body reaches when active defense is not possible.

Disclaimer: By listening to this podcast, you agree not to use this podcast as medical, psychological, or mental health advice to treat any medical or psychological condition in yourself or others. This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult your own physician, therapist, psychiatrist, or other qualified health provider regarding any physical or mental health issues you may be experiencing.

Comment Etiquette: I would love to hear your thoughts on this episode. Please share and use your name or initials so that we can keep this space spam-free and the discussion positive 😌