Is Emotional Eating a Trauma Response? How Attachment and Biochemistry Shape Cravings, with Dr. Aimie Apigian
Emotional eating can be a trauma response, and so can restricting food. In both, the body is using food to help with something that once felt like too much: eating puts space between us and an overwhelming feeling, and restricting gives a sense of control when the rest of life feels out of our hands.
Many people blame themselves for cravings, or try to force their body into a stricter diet. Dr. Aimie Apigian sees cravings differently. After decades of hearing people describe their relationship with food, she looks at what the craving is helping with, where that pattern first started, and what the body may actually be missing.
In this teaching from one of her Biology of Trauma® courses, Dr. Aimie explains how our earliest relationships shape our cravings, why some bodies need more protein than others, how the state of the nervous system shapes which foods we reach for, and the three pieces that help so food does not have to carry it all.
Dr. Aimie Apigian is a double board-certified physician in preventive medicine and addiction medicine and the author of The Biology of Trauma.
TL;DR: Emotional eating and restrictive eating are both ways the body tries to help us through overwhelm. Their roots often go back to early attachment, which also shapes our biochemistry and what the body craves. Support comes from three pieces together: the biology, the somatic work and the parts work.
WHY WOULD EMOTIONAL EATING HELP THE BODY?
Emotional eating creates a different sensation in the body when a feeling is too uncomfortable to stay with. Dr. Aimie describes it as a way to put space between us and the feeling. That space helps with overwhelm, and it can also keep us in chronic functional freeze, because we are not feeling our feelings.
WHY DO SOME PEOPLE RESTRICT FOOD WHEN THEY FEEL OUT OF CONTROL?
Restrictive eating often gives a sense of control when nothing else feels controllable. The most common thing Dr. Aimie has heard over the decades is that food intake is the one place a person can still be in charge. For people who develop anorexia, feeling trapped and controlled by others is a common theme.
HOW DOES ATTACHMENT SHAPE CRAVINGS?
Attachment shapes cravings in two ways. Early programming can lead a child who felt controlled to take control through food, and the same wiring can lead an adult into relationships where they feel trapped. Attachment also shapes biochemistry. Dr. Aimie explains that the early attachment relationship is a big part of forming the dopamine system, so neurotransmitter imbalances can start in early life and build up over time. Research supports the link between attachment and eating: a 2018 meta-analysis of 70 studies and 19,470 people found that higher attachment insecurity was associated with more unhealthy eating behaviors.
Attachment: the early relationship with our caregivers, which programs how safe we feel with people and helps form our neurotransmitter systems.
WHY DO SOME BODIES CRAVE MORE PROTEIN?
All neurotransmitters, including serotonin and dopamine, are made from amino acids, which come from protein. When neurotransmitter activity is low, the body craves what it needs to make more. About 90% of the body's serotonin is made in the gut, and the gut also produces a large share of the body's dopamine, so gut health and the microbiome affect these needs too.
People with undermethylation, a biochemical imbalance, typically need more protein than others. Dr. Aimie notes that she has never known an undermethylator who did not also build up stress and trauma because of those traits. When an undermethylator chooses a low-protein diet, intense cravings can follow, and starting the day with protein can steady blood sugar and reduce sugar cravings.
Undermethylation: a biochemical imbalance in which the body needs more protein than usual; Dr. Aimie links its traits to rumination and an obsessive or addictive personality.
WHAT ARE THE THREE PIECES THAT HELP WITH CRAVINGS?
The three pieces are the biology, the somatic work and the parts work, and all three are needed. The biology asks what the body is trying to help with through this particular food. The somatic work builds other ways to create distance from a feeling. The parts work meets the part that developed the craving as a way to cope.
WHY DOES A PART OF US RESIST GIVING UP A FOOD?
A part of us may have developed the craving to protect a younger, scared part that never got what it needed. Asking it to give up the food can feel like asking it to let that pain through. Dr. Aimie also describes the part that learned to people-please, which meant having no needs, and so reaches for foods that numb its own needs or give quick energy to meet someone else's.
HOW DOES THE NERVOUS SYSTEM DECIDE WHICH FOODS WE REACH FOR?
The body uses food to stay within its window of tolerance. With a strong pull toward freeze, it craves foods that bring it out of freeze. When running high in sympathetic stress near the line of overwhelm, it reaches for things that calm it down, such as alcohol or marijuana. Tracking the nervous system alongside cravings helps a person see the pattern and ask what this food would be helping with right now.
Window of tolerance: the range in which the nervous system can stay present and regulated without tipping into overwhelm or freeze.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Emotional eating creates space between us and an overwhelming feeling.
Restrictive eating often gives a sense of control when the rest of life feels controlled by others.
Both patterns are the body trying to help, and both can keep us in chronic functional freeze.
The question that leads to the root is when we first felt this way.
Early attachment helps form the dopamine system, so cravings can have biochemical roots in early life.
All neurotransmitters are made from amino acids, and low-protein diets can leave some bodies craving intensely.
Undermethylators typically need more protein, and starting the day with protein can steady blood sugar.
Support for cravings takes the biology, the somatic work and the parts work together.
A protective part may hold on to a food to keep a younger part's pain from overwhelming us.
Freeze pulls us toward foods that bring us up; high sympathetic stress pulls us toward things that calm us down.
NOTABLE QUOTES (LIGHTLY EDITED FOR CLARITY)
"When we eat emotionally, food creates a different sensation in the body. It puts some space between us and a feeling that is too much." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"Over the decades, the most common thing I have heard about restrictive eating is that it gives a sense of control." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"When nothing else in life feels in our control, we can still control what we put in our mouth." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"To get to the root of a craving, ask: when did I first feel this way? That's where we need to go." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"We struggle with diets because the body is trying to get the amino acids it needs to make the neurotransmitters we are low in." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"We think our body needs to be whipped into shape and told what to do, not realizing it is desperately craving what it needs to help us." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"I have never known an undermethylator who didn't also build up stress and trauma in their life because of their undermethylation traits." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"The part of us that reaches for food is often protecting a young, scared part of us that never got what it needed." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"If we learned to people-please, we learned we couldn't have needs. So we may reach for foods that keep us from feeling our own needs, or that give us quick energy to meet someone else's." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"Our body is trying to be healthy. It is trying desperately to keep us within our window of tolerance, and it uses food to do that." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"Genetics, attachment, neurodevelopment, grief, gut health: it's all one system." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
"When we lean toward freeze, the body craves foods that lift us out of it. When we run high in stress, it reaches for things that calm us down." ~ Dr. Aimie Apigian
EPISODE TAKEAWAY
For decades I have listened to people describe their relationship with food. Some tell me they eat to fill an emptiness inside. Others tell me that food is the one thing in their life they can still control. These sound like opposite problems. When I look at them through the biology of trauma, I see the same thing underneath: a body doing its best to help.
When a feeling is too much, eating creates a different sensation, and that sensation puts some space between us and the feeling. When life feels like it is controlled by other people, deciding what goes into our mouth gives us one place where we are in charge. Both help us survive something that once felt overwhelming. Both can also keep us in a chronic functional freeze, because they keep us from feeling what is underneath.
So I always ask: when did this first start? When did you first feel this way? That question usually leads to attachment. If we felt controlled as a child, food may have become the one place we could take control back. If, as adults, we find ourselves trapped in a relationship, our attachment wiring is part of how we got there.
Attachment also shapes our biochemistry. Our earliest relationships help form our dopamine system, and imbalances that start in early life build up over time. Our neurotransmitters are made from amino acids, which come from protein, so a body that is low in these chemicals will crave what it needs. This is why a low-protein diet can feel like chaos for some people, especially for undermethylators, who typically need more protein than others. They often think their body needs to be whipped into shape. Their body is asking for what it needs.
Knowing this changes how we approach cravings. We bring in three pieces together. The biology helps us understand what the body is trying to get from this food. The somatic work gives us other ways to create distance from a feeling. The parts work helps us meet the part that developed the craving, often to protect a younger part of us that never got what it needed. That protective part is not ready to give up the food until it knows the younger part will be cared for.
The nervous system shapes all of this. If we tend toward freeze, we reach for foods that lift us. If we run high in sympathetic stress, we reach for things that calm us down. When we track where our nervous system is each time a craving shows up, we start to see the pattern, and we can ask what this food would be helping with right now.
This is the Biology of Trauma® approach: we look at the whole system, genetics, attachment, neurodevelopment, grief and gut health together, and we work with the body. If you want to understand which patterns of stored trauma your body may be running, the 2-Minute Assessment for Stored Trauma is a good place to start. When you are ready to go deeper, The Foundational Journey is where we build the safety and capacity the body needs before it can let go of what it has been holding.
FAQ
Is emotional eating a trauma response?
It can be. Emotional eating helps the body create space from a feeling that is too much, which is the same job a trauma response does. It often traces back to early life and attachment.
Is restrictive eating a sign of trauma?
Restricting food often gives a sense of control when other parts of life feel controlled by others. Dr. Aimie traces that pattern back to early programming, such as feeling controlled as a child.
Can attachment affect what I crave?
Yes. Early attachment helps form the dopamine system, and neurotransmitter imbalances that start in early life can drive cravings for what the body needs to make those chemicals.
Why do I crave sugar on a low-protein diet?
Without enough protein, blood sugar swings through the day and the body craves quick sugar. Some people, such as undermethylators, need more protein than others, and starting the day with protein can steady those swings.
Why is it so hard to give up a comfort food?
A part of us may be holding on to the food to protect a younger part that still feels scared and alone. Giving up the food can feel like letting that pain through, which is why parts work matters here.
Why do I reach for different foods in different moods?
The nervous system uses food to stay within its window of tolerance. In freeze, it reaches for foods that lift it; in high stress, it reaches for things that calm it down.
What is the psychology behind comfort eating?
Comfort eating is the body using food to change how it feels when a feeling is too much. Dr. Aimie traces it to the nervous system and to early attachment, which shapes both how we cope and what our body craves.
Why do I eat until I feel uncomfortably full?
Eating past fullness creates a strong physical sensation, and Dr. Aimie explains that this sensation puts space between us and a feeling that is too much. The discomfort is doing a job: it numbs what we do not want to feel.
If food calms my nervous system, what else can?
The somatic work gives the body other ways to create distance from a feeling, and parts work helps the part that relies on food. Tracking where the nervous system is when a craving shows up shows which kind of support it needs.
What are the psychological reasons behind food cravings?
Cravings carry information. Some come from what the body is missing, such as protein to make neurotransmitters. Others come from a protective part of us that uses food to keep an old pain from overwhelming us.
IN THIS EPISODE
00:00 Why do some of us eat and others stop eating when stressed?
01:14 How can emotional eating and restrictive eating help the body?
01:56 Why does restricting food feel like control?
03:47 How does attachment lead to feeling trapped and out of control?
04:41 How does attachment shape our neurotransmitters and cravings?
07:01 Why do undermethylators need more protein?
11:29 What are the three pieces that help with cravings?
12:25 Why does a part of us hold on to a food?
14:42 How does the nervous system decide which foods we reach for?
RESOURCES/GUIDES
Take the free 2-Minute Assessment for Stored Trauma. See which patterns of stored trauma your body may be running.
Get The Biology of Trauma book by Dr. Aimie Apigian. Chapter 11, "Vulnerability for Trauma: Early Life and Preexisting Filters," covers undermethylation and attachment.
RELATED PODCAST EPISODES
What Food Cravings Reveal About Stress, Trauma, and Childhood Needs, with Dr. Tian Dayton (Episode 181). For the listener who wants to map their own cravings back to childhood.
How Attachment Shapes Our Biology and Behavior (Episode 69). For the listener who wants the full picture of attachment in the body.
How Attachment Affects Us For Life: 6 Childhood Pains and How to Repair (Episode 146). For the listener who wants to know which early attachment pains their body still carries.
YOUR HOST
Dr. Aimie Apigian is a double board-certified physician in preventive medicine and addiction medicine and the author of The Biology of Trauma. She is the founder of Trauma Healing Accelerated®, where her online programs combine the biology, somatic work and parts work.
RESEARCH
Yano JM, et al. Indigenous bacteria from the gut microbiota regulate host serotonin biosynthesis. Cell. 2015;161(2):264-276.
Eisenhofer G, et al. Substantial production of dopamine in the human gastrointestinal tract. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1997;82(11):3864-3871.
Faber A, Dubé L, Knäuper B. Attachment and eating: A meta-analytic review of the relevance of attachment for unhealthy and healthy eating behaviors in the general population. Appetite. 2018;123:410-438.
Note for publishing: do not add the "90% of people with an addiction or OCD are undermethylators" figure from the audio. No study was named, and it is left out until Dr. Aimie gives a source.
Transcript
DISCLAIMER
This episode is educational and is not medical advice. Please work with your own qualified healthcare provider for decisions about your care.

Comments